My old Honeywell keyboard died so I tried some replacement keyboards and the most expensive replacement was the least satisfactory. What should you look for in a keyboard?
The key movement is the most important factor and none of the tested keyboards are as good as my old Honeywell. Bring back Honeywell keyboards.
The Honeywell keyboard dates from last century and in 1993 Honeywell sold their keyboard manufacturing to Keytronics, so my keyboard could be from earlier than 1993. The first really good keyboard that I used was an IBM keyboard using metal slides on the keys and magnetic switches that provided perfect bounce. The Honeywell keyboards where the only other keyboards to perfect movement and retain reliability.
Reliability
Cheap keyboards bend because they have no metal frame and the cheap plastic substitute is not rigid. Cheap plastic keys create friction when they slide and wear out quickly. Metal, two dissimilar non corrosive metals are perfect, create the smoothest slide and can be lubricated. The closest equivalent in plastic requires an intermediate Teflon sleeve, silicon lubricant, really good design, and careful manufacturing, none of which are present in cheap keyboards.
Cheap keyboards can be accidentally good when new because the manufacturer used the right design and materials but it usually does not last because the soft slippery plastics wear out. Cheap keyboards have no design targets while medium quality keyboards last ten million keystrokes and the most reliable keyboards last fifty million keystrokes.
Is ten million keystrokes a lot of keystrokes? There are over 100 keys on a keyboard which means an individual key has to survive only 500 thousand keystrokes. Some keys are used more than others, which means you could strike the space key, or another popular key, 500 thousand times before the z key, or a similarly less popular key, is struck less than 10 thousand times. The imbalance of usage means a high usage key will fail when you use your keyboard perhaps only two million times.
What is two million keystrokes to the average typist? A word can average eight keystrokes which means a word and a space use nine keystrokes. Allowing for the occasional backspace, allow ten keystrokes per word which brings two million keystrokes back to 200 thousand words or one hundred pages.
Most keyboards last longer because the usage is more evenly distributed but some usage is out of proportion. When you type indented text, you can use a small number of tab keys or a large number of spaces. I use tabs. Some typists use spaces and destroy their spacebar long before the rest of they keyboard is worn out.
So how long did my old Honeywell keyboard last? I purchased one Honeywell keyboard back when they had metal frames, which would easily be before 1993, then another just as they converted to plastic frames, which would be the early 1990s or late 1980s. The first keyboard was foolishly given away with a computer because I thought I could get more Honeywell keyboards forever. The second keyboard suffered the bulk of my big handed thumping.
The average novel is 220 pages. My first full book was 1100 pages before the editors cut it back to the 880 pages that the publishers had allocated. Allow for my working toward perfection, something impossible in writing, and the average page was typed, retypes, edited, and reedited three times. That makes the 1100 page manuscript a 3300 page effort, or 15 novels. Pick up 15 novels and imagine typing them.
That 3300 pages of typing was completed in six months. Repeat that twice per year for most of the years from 1993 to the end of 2006. 24 years by two lots of six months by 3300 pages. That is over 150 thousand pages. In fact I slacked off on some years and the total would be less than 100 thousand pages. If one keyboard can last 100 thousand pages and another keyboard can be faulty after 100 pages, you can see why a slight extra investment in a good keyboard can repay itself many times over.
RSI
RSI, or Repetitive Strain Injury, is related to stress as are some forms of arthritis and many other diseases. A good keyboard lets you type an 1100 page book without stress which a bad keyboard creates stress from about 20 minutes into the first chapter.
The perfect keyboard for you is not the perfect keyboard for me or anyone else as the keyboard has to fit your hands and balance the weight of your keystrokes. If the keyboard is too light, you will strain yourself trying to not type more than you want and if the keyboard is too resistive, you will wear yourself out thumping the keys. The only valid test is to type for an hour, take a short break then try typing for another hour.
Feel
When you use a keyboard, you press a key down until you feel or hear a click then you release the key. Feeling the click is more important that hearing the click because your fingers can react immediately to the feel. Audible clicks are just distractions that jumble with all the other clicks in your office. The best keyboards have good feel and almost no noise.
You feel a very light springy resistance to the downward stroke, just enough to stop you accidentally pressing a key. On a great keyboard, you feel the click part way down and can immediately release the key, with the spring returning your finger and key to the original up position. The perfect feel uses hysteresis, which was originally related to the magnetic component in early keyboards. The stroke downwards is slightly different to the stroke upwards and the result is an upward pressure immediately the keystroke activates the keyboard, followed by a spring backwards that lifts your finger up without you having to stress yourself.
On some keyboards you do not feel anything until the key hits the bottom of the stroke and your fingers go crunch into the key. Modern membrane keys are notorious for having no spring at the bottom of the keystroke. The better keyboards have a thicker springier membrane to bounce you back and the really good keyboards have metal springs to bounce you back.
Noise
The cheapest keyboards are rattly squeaky rubbish because they are made of the wrong plastics and poorly finished. Some of the more expensive keyboards are equally noisy because the designers are deaf. The designers must sit all day with their heads jammed between laser printers and shredders, until they are deaf as cardboard boxes. They then design keyboards that feel and sound like they are made from cardboard boxes. The worst of those keyboards end up on Dell computers.
Luckily for Dell users, not all Dell computers get cardboard keyboards and, strangely, the cardboard feel is not directly related to price as shown by one of my $20 cheap keyboards working better than a $125 major brand keyboard. The $125 keyboard might last longer than the $20 keyboard but I would rather type on a succession of the $20 keyboards than the $125 keyboard.
Technical Stuff
There are some technical measurements you can look for in a keyboard but do not expect to find them except for a few rare expensive keyboards.
Travel
Travel is the measurement of a keystroke length. If the keystroke is too shore, you cannot swing your fingers enough to circulate blood through your muscles. If the keystroke is too long, you waste time, a common problem with old mechanical typewriters. 4 mm to 5 mm, about a fifth of an inch for Americans, is a comfortable distance for my large fingers and 2 mm, less than a tenth of an inch, is comfortable for ladies with dainty hands and long fingernails.
That comment about dainty hands and long fingernails is because an ex girlfriend, from back in the days when I was single and interested in lots of single women instead of finding one true life partner, had fingernails longer than the knife I used to take the skin off oranges. At work we spent some time together finding her exactly the right keyboard so she could type without endangering her nails. The result was a very flat keyboard with very short travel, a keyboard design that is popular today because it is cheaper to manufacture.
Pre Travel
This is the distance the key travels before activating the letter, number, or character. You need a pre travel long enough to pump blood around your muscles. If you get pain in your muscles then it could be lactic acid build up from not enough movement.
Activation Travel
This is the distance the key travels when activating the letter, number, or character. The distance should be immeasurably small but some sloppy keyboards have a significant variation. A bad keyboard will show activation travel as a need to press keys a long way sometimes while a short distance other times. You can also get keyboards where two keys sitting next to each other will require different movements to activate them.
the ideal keyboard has exactly the same movement to activate every key and just slightly more pressure to activate the spacebar so that you will not accidentally knock the spacebar while reaching for the keys along the top of the keyboard.
Post Travel
The most important part of the travel is the post travel, which is total travel minus pre travel and any actuation travel. Post travel is the distance your fingers have to stop moving before crashing into the bottom of the stroke. You want post travel at least as far as the pre travel and a gradual increase in back pressure during the post travel so that your fingers can bounce back naturally.
Activation Force
Cherry quote an activation force of 60 cN for one of their keyboards and their competitors quote from 30 grams up to 80 grams with 50 grams being an average. You want 30 or 40 grams for the light touch hands, 60 grams for my heavier fingers and 80 grams for the spacebar to prevent accidental activation.
Keytronic inherited the Honeywell keyboard and have a fascinating range of keyboards I cannot find on retail sale in Australia. The following image is from their site and relates to their Eurotech keyboard which is the closest I can see to the old Honeywell keyboard. If their Eurotech keyboard has the lovely feel of the old Honeywell keyboards then Australian shops should sell it instead of the usual dull Logitech and even less interesting Microsoft keyboards.
Keytronic Ergo_Technology:
Keystrokes Before Failure
Cheap keyboards are designed to survive only their 30 day guarantees. Medium keyboards last ten million keystrokes while the top keyboards last 50 million keystrokes or more. Some keyboards last a long time but only if you thump them progressively harder. Some keyboards will die if you spill coffee on them while others will survive through coffee as rough as Starbucks coffee.
The keystrokes measurement assumes even use and not the constant thump on one key that you get with some games, or the phosphoric acid attack of some cola based drinks. The thin electrical contacts assume you are not near salty ocean breezes or the constant humidity of a Darwin summer.
For a good brand the measurements are based on average conditions while the lesser brands base their tests on climate controlled clean air environments with key pressures matched to the needs of the keyboard, not they user. Within a brand, there can be a range of models from great down to the bottom of the cheap/nasty rejects from second rate Chinese factories. Manufacturers do themselves a disservice by placing the cheap/nasty products in the same brand as the good stuff.
Keystrokes before failure is a good guide to reliability if they keyboard fits your normal stroke pressure and length. If there is the slightest mismatch then you will strain your hands or they keyboard and your hands/keyboard will fail early.
Conclusion
Choose a keyboard that fits your typing style and hands. Type for two hours straight and feel the result. If there is the slightest strain on your hands or arms then choose another keyboard. The perfect keyboard is out there and will cost a little bit extra but will require many hours of work to find it. My comments might just help you find the perfect keyboard before painful lumps appear in your wrist.
Further reading
- Facebook Like
- Google Plus One
- Log in or register to post comments